Risk Analysis for Mining and Metals | Vose Software

Industries / Mining and metals

What is the mine really worth?

Put ranges on grade, recovery and metal prices, and see what they mean for life-of-mine NPV and the investment case.

  • ModelRisk
  • Tamara
  • ModelChoice
  • Pelican

NPV of a copper mine

10,000 futures

NPV $0
14%lose money86%make money
Project NPV, US$ million
14% lose money86% make money
Illustrative A mine valuation with copper price, grade, recovery, capex, opex and timing uncertain.

One NPV hides a 14% chance of losing money. The range shows it, and the drivers say why.

Clients in mining and metals

  • Anglo American
  • Nutrien
  • EuroChem
  • Evolution Mining
  • Samarco
  • Lithium Americas
  • De Grey Mining

Questions we answer

The questions your board asks, with the numbers behind them

Charts marked with a model code come from a free example model you can open in Excel. The others are marked illustrative.

Where each product fits:
1ExploreModelChoice

Explore in full, in phases, or sell the rights?

Pay for information before committing. Phased exploration has the highest expected value, $15.6M, against $13.6M for a full programme and $2.0M for selling the rights.

Full Exploration ProgramEV $13.6MPhased ExplorationEV $15.6MBestSell Exploration RightsEV $2.0M

From the free example Mining Exploration Decision, rolled back in ModelChoice.
2StudyModelRisk

What is in the ground?

See how early technical uncertainty flows into production potential and mine life.

P90 808 kt
10%below90%above
Payable copper, kilotonnes
10% below90% above
Illustrative Payable copper from tonnage, grade, dilution and recovery: P90 808, P50 1,000, P10 1,192 kt.
3ApproveModelRisk

What drives the value?

See the whole range of value and what drives the downside, instead of one NPV and three scenarios.

Copper priceHead gradeRecoveryCapexOpexFirst-ore date−$200M$0M$200M$400M$600M$800M
Mean NPV with each input at its low or high end, US$ million
Lowers the NPVRaises the NPVMean NPV
Illustrative The same mine as the chart at the top of the page.
4BuildModelRisk

What will it cost to develop?

Set contingency for the confidence level you need instead of a flat 15%. Here the estimate holds in a third of futures and P80 needs $943M.

Estimate $820M
33%within the estimate67%over it
Development capex, US$ million
33% within the estimate67% over it
Illustrative Capex by package with risk events: the $820M estimate is 33% likely, P80 is $943M.
4BuildTamara

When will we get first ore?

Find which activities drive the date before you commit to offtake.

Months from approval
Critical path in the planOther tasksPlan80% of futures finish in this range
19% on plan81% late

The plan says first ore in month 32.

Only 19% of futures make month 32; P80 is month 37.6.

Illustrative A mine development schedule with three-point durations and a 25% chance of a permit appeal. 10,000 futures.
5OperateModelRisk

What will the mine deliver?

Link operational uncertainty to the production and cash flow of the life-of-mine plan.

020406080100120Y1Y2Y3Y4Y5Y6Y7Y8
Copper produced, kilotonnes a year
10th to 90th percentileMedian forecastMine plan
Illustrative The mine plan sits above the median forecast through ramp-up.
5OperateTamara

How long will the shutdown really take?

Plan maintenance windows and lost production on realistic durations.

Days from shutdown
Critical path in the planOther tasksPlan80% of futures finish in this range
18% on plan82% overrun

The plan says 14 days.

Only 18% of futures finish in 14 days; P80 is 16.9 days.

Illustrative A mill shutdown with three-point durations and a 20% chance of finding damage during the reline. 10,000 futures.
6OptimiseModelRisk

Expand now, or start small and decide later?

Value the option to wait as well as the decision to build. Starting small and deciding later has the highest mean NPV; building big now loses money in 36.4% of futures.

NPV $0
36.4%lose money63.6%make money
NPV, US$ million
36.4% lose money63.6% make money

Mean NPV $16.1M

From the free example model CF-08 Real Options: Expand or Abandon, a production plant. The same real-options method values a mine expansion. 10,000 futures.
+Every sitePelican

What risks are we carrying across every site?

One register for HSE, operational and project risk, through to closure. It exchanges risks and results with Tamara and takes in results from your ModelRisk models.

SiteRiskOwnerBeforeAfterStatus
North PitSlope instabilityGeotechnical lead208Mitigating
Process plantMill liner failureMaintenance manager166Mitigating
TailingsSeepage from the tailings damEnvironment manager156Mitigating
Haul roadsLight vehicle interactionHSE manager164Mitigating
PortShipping delayLogistics manager126Open
Illustrative A group register with scores before and after mitigation (5 × 5 scale).

How it fits together

One integrated model, from the ground to the investment decision

Built in ModelRisk, in Excel.

  1. Step 1 · ModelRiskReserves and geologyTonnage, grade, recovery.
  2. Step 2 · ModelRiskCapEx, OpEx and risksCost ranges and discrete risk events.
  3. Step 3 · ModelRiskCash-flow modelVolumes, revenue, costs.
  4. Step 4 · ModelRiskCommodity pricesPrice paths and correlations.OG-04
  5. Step 5 · ModelRiskSimulation and insightsPercentiles, drivers, scenarios.

Training

Risk analysis training

Risk analysis modelling courses can focus on your industry and on the problems you model, online or face-to-face.

See the courses

Consulting

Bring one mine model

Our consultants review your resource, valuation or schedule model before a critical decision or a public review.

See consulting

FAQ

Common questions

Why not add 15% contingency to the capex estimate?

A flat percentage says nothing about how likely the budget is to hold. Simulating the cost ranges and risk events gives the budget at each confidence level, so you can set contingency at P80 or at whatever level your board chooses.

Can ModelChoice value staged exploration?

Yes. The free Mining Exploration example compares a full programme, a phased programme and selling the rights, with a commodity price cycle in the chance nodes. Phased exploration has the highest expected value, $15.6M.

Do we have to leave Excel?

No. ModelRisk and ModelChoice are Excel add-ins: you add ranges, risk events and decisions to the workbooks you already have. Tamara works on your Primavera P6 or Microsoft Project schedule.

Can we try it on one of our own models?

Yes. ModelRisk, ModelChoice and Tamara each have a free 15-day trial, and our team can go through one of your own models with you.

Bring one mine plan. We'll show you the range.

Free 15-day trials of ModelRisk, ModelChoice and Tamara. For Pelican, we'll show it to you on risks like yours.