Cash Flow at Risk: FX and Interest Rates | Vose Software

ModelRisk example · Corporate finance

Currency and Interest-Rate Exposure

How much cash could currency and interest-rate moves cost, and how much does hedging half of it save?

  • Complexity: ★★★★★
  • Free Excel workbook (CF-05)
  • Needs ModelRisk: free trial

From the model’s saved run

Cash flow at risk

Cash flow over the three years (€m). Cash flow at risk = mean − 5th percentile.

PolicyMean5th pctCash flow at riskChance of a negative quarter95th pct
Unhedged35.6−23.258.845.3%99.9
Hedging policy30.41.129.424.5%62.6
Unhedged, if the markets were independent35.7−37.873.453.4%115.0
MeasureUnitValue
Cash flow over 3 years at today's rates€m32.7
Cash flow over 3 years — cumulative probability

The business question

A European engineering company invoices its US customers about US$45 million a quarter. It makes most of what it sells in a UK plant whose costs are about £20 million a quarter, has €12 million of other costs, and pays Euribor plus 1.75% on a €250 million loan.

At today's rates the business generates about €2.7 million a quarter — thin enough that a weaker dollar or a stronger pound could turn a quarter negative. The dollar and the pound tend to move together against the euro, which partly protects the company: its dollar revenue and sterling costs move in the same direction.

The board is considering a policy of hedging half of each exposure: forward contracts for the currencies and an interest-rate swap for the loan. The model simulates the three markets together for twelve quarters.

Who it is for
Treasurers, CFOs and risk committees setting a hedging policy; FP&A teams forecasting cash in several currencies.
Main outputs
Cash flow over three years, unhedged and hedged: mean, 5th percentile and cash flow at risk · the chance of a negative quarter · the effect of the correlation between the dollar and the pound · quarterly cash flow fan · drivers.

How the model works

Three sheets after this one, read from left to right. Each one feeds the next.

  1. Inputs sheet

    The dollar sales, sterling and euro costs and the loan. Today's exchange rates and interest rates; the annual volatility of each market and the correlations between them. The share of each exposure hedged and the swap rate.

  2. Cash flow sheet

    VoseTimeMultiGBM draws twelve quarters of the three markets together from their covariance matrix. Each quarter, the dollar sales and sterling costs are converted at that quarter's rates, and the loan pays Euribor plus its margin. The hedged version fixes half of each at today's forward rates and the swap rate.

  3. Results sheet

    Cash flow over three years — its mean, 5th percentile and cash flow at risk — unhedged, hedged and with independent currencies. The chance of a negative quarter; quarter by quarter; the drivers.

ModelRisk techniques

  • Multivariate GBM VoseTimeMultiGBM
  • Forwards from interest differentials
  • Hedging policy on the same paths
  • Independent currencies for comparison
  • Fan chart and S-curves

Find similar models

Product

The results in detail

Which hedge share?

Every share from the unhedged run, exactly: in every future the hedged cash flow is (1 − share) × unhedged + share × fully hedged (€m over 3 years).

Quarterly cash flow, unhedged — 10th to 90th percentile
Share hedgedMean5th pctCash flow at riskCost of the hedge
0%35.6−23.258.80.0
25%33.0−11.044.12.6
50%30.41.129.45.2
75%27.813.214.77.8
100%25.325.30.010.4

Cost of the hedge: the mean cash flow given up against no hedge. The policy row above is the row at the share on the Inputs sheet.

Quarter by quarter

How many of the twelve quarters turn negative.

MeasureUnit5th pctMedian95th pctMean
Negative quarters, unhedgedof 12––10.02.3
Negative quarters, hedgedof 12––6.01.0

The dollar

EUR/USD by quarter: the further ahead, the wider the range.

EUR/USD by quarter — 10th to 90th percentile
MeasureUnit10th pctMedian90th pctMean
Average EUR/USD over the 3 yearsUSD/EUR0.9831.0971.2251.101

What drives the cash flow

Lowest and highest mean cash flow over ten equal groups of each market's average (VoseSimSensitivityMean), drawn from the overall mean.

What drives the unhedged cash flow (€m)
The ranking as a table 3 inputs
Input (ranked by influence)Lowest meanHighest meanRank
EUR/USD level−18.098.81
Euribor level27.341.32
EUR/GBP level30.542.13

How to read these results

  • A weaker dollar (a higher EUR/USD) cuts the euro value of the sales. A weaker pound (a higher EUR/GBP) cuts the euro cost of the UK plant. Unhedged, the cash flow over three years can fall far below what today's rates promise, and the chance of at least one negative quarter is close to one half.
  • Hedging half of each exposure halves the cash flow at risk and nearly halves the chance of a negative quarter, but it is not free. Dollar and sterling interest rates are above Euribor, so the forward rates are above today's rates and the dollars sold forward buy fewer euros: the hedge costs about €5 million of average cash flow over the three years.

    The rest is the business's own exposure, which the hedge share sets. The hedge-share table shows every choice at once: the cash flow at risk shrinks in proportion to the share left unhedged, and the cost grows with the share hedged.

  • The dollar and the pound tend to move together against the euro, so the sales and the UK costs partly offset: with independent markets the cash flow at risk would be clearly larger. A hedge that ignored this correlation would over-hedge.
  • The tornado chart shows EUR/USD as the driver: the mean cash flow runs from about €99 million in the tenth of futures with the weakest euro down to about −€18 million in the tenth with the strongest.

    The bar for EUR/GBP is small, and it is mostly EUR/USD's effect: a strong euro against the pound comes with a strong euro against the dollar, so the cash flow is lower there, although a cheaper pound lowers the UK costs. A tornado measures association, not cause, when inputs are correlated. Euribor matters little: the loan costs much less than the currency swings.

See it move. Open the workbook, change an input on the Inputs sheet and run the simulation: every table and chart on this page updates in Excel.

Inputs and assumptions

Every assumption in the model, with its uncertainty and where it comes from. The figures are illustrative.

Exposures 5 inputs

Each quarter.

AssumptionUnitValue
Sales in US dollarsUS customers, invoiced in dollars.US$m per quarter45.0
UK plant costs£m per quarter20.0
Other costs€m per quarter12.0
Floating-rate loan€m250.0
Loan margin over Euriborper year1.75%
Markets today 5 inputs

Spot rates and the interest rates that set the forward rates.

AssumptionUnitValue
EUR/USDUSD per EUR1.1000
EUR/GBPGBP per EUR0.8500
Euriborper year2.50%
US dollar interest rateFor the forward rates.per year4.00%
Sterling interest rateper year3.75%
Market risk 5 inputs

Annual volatilities of the log changes, and their correlations.

AssumptionUnitValue
Volatility of EUR/USDThree years of weekly changes.per year8.0%
Volatility of EUR/GBPper year6.0%
Volatility of Euribor (relative)Of the log of the rate.per year20.0%
Correlation: EUR/USD vs EUR/GBPThe dollar and the pound tend to move together against the euro.-1 to 10.50
Correlation: exchange rates vs Euribor-1 to 10.00
Hedging policy 2 inputs

Applied to every quarter from today.

AssumptionUnitValue
Share of each exposure hedgedForwards for the currencies, a swap for the loan.50%
Swap rate (fixed, replaces Euribor)Three-year swap quote.per year2.70%

Units and conventions

Money
€ million (€m); dollar and sterling amounts in US$m and £m.
Exchange rates
Units of foreign currency per euro: a higher EUR/USD is a weaker dollar.
Cash flow at risk
The mean cash flow less its 5th percentile: how much worse than expected one year in twenty could be.
Quarters
Quarter 1 is the next quarter; twelve quarters, three years.

Key assumptions and limitations

Markets
Log changes are Normal and their volatilities and correlations constant; today's rates are the median forecast.
Hedging
Forwards and the swap are agreed today for all twelve quarters; no credit risk or margin calls.
Business
Volumes and local-currency prices are fixed: only the markets move the cash flow.
Data
The company and all figures are invented for this example.

How to use it

  1. Enter your quarterly exposures, today's market rates and your hedging policy on the Inputs sheet.
  2. Set the volatilities and correlations from market data (for example three years of weekly changes).
  3. Run a simulation from the ModelRisk ribbon (10,000 samples with a fixed seed are set).
  4. Choose the hedge share whose cash flow at risk the company can carry.

Simulate this model with ModelRisk’s classic engine: it does not run in Turbo mode yet.

ModelRisk functions used

VoseTimeMultiGBM
EUR/USD, EUR/GBP and Euribor for twelve quarters, drawn together from a covariance matrix.
VoseInput, VoseOutput
Name the drivers and the cash flows as outputs.
VoseSimMean, VoseSimPercentile
Statistics of the simulation for the tables and charts on the Results sheet.
VoseSimSensitivityMean
The tornado chart: every VoseInput ranked by how far the mean unhedged cash flow moves across its range.

Further reading